Salam ( Greeting of peace ):
Welcome
Please feel free to communicate with us and share your thoughts…. We will be posting your contributions to this site seeking those things that in a similar fashion keep us united and together in the pursuance of a better world. Blessings…
Search This Blog
Original forgiveness instead of the so called original sin
Greetings of peace,
This post is an answer to a new friend whom I recently met and respect , a devout Christian passionate about sharing his religion with others , who challenged me to provide some proofs regarding why Muslims don't accept the doctrine of original sin; a doctrine ( including the concept of trinity ) that was added by the Church at the Council of Nicaea some 325 years after Jesus left the earth. Notice I say left the earth ( meaning resurrected alive by Allah ) and not died yet or crucify as some claims , but that is a topic for another day. Back to the doctrine of original sin.
Are we born with so called Original sin or born innocent ?
Is a Newly Born Baby really a Sinner? Islam Challenges The Concept of Original Sin. Let us found out why ?
let's take a look at the following passages from The Bible:
(Deuteronomy 24:16)
“The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers, every man shall be put to death for his own sin.”
(Jeremiah 31:30): “But every one shall die for his own iniquity...”
(Ezekiel 18:20): “The soul that sinneth, it shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father; neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son; the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him.”
After reading the above verses, would you not agree that The Bible itself teaches that each of us is responsible for our own actions?
Let us ponder what the Quran has to say :
“And no bearer of burdens shall bear another’s burden”. (Quran 35:18)
Quran 35:18
And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. And if a heavily laden soul calls [another] to [carry some of] its load, nothing of it will be carried, even if he should be a close relative. You can only warn those who fear their Lord unseen and have established prayer. And whoever purifies himself only purifies himself for [the benefit of] his soul. And to Allah is the [final] destination.
So it would seem that The Bible and Quran are in agreement on this topic. And as we go along further on this journey of truth-seeking, we'll see that this happens more often than not.
The doctrine of original sin in Spanish translated by Dr. Jesus Marti cohost and translator for Islam4mankind weekly Radio program :
Saludo dePaz,Esta sección es una respuesta a unbuen amigo a quién recientemente tuve el placer de conocer y por quién sientoun profundo respeto y admiración, un devoto Cristiano quién apasionadamentecomparte su religión con otros, quién me reta a proveerle pruebas sobre porquelos Musulmanes no aceptamos la Doctrina del Pecado Original; una Doctrina(Incluyendo el Concepto de la Trinidad) que fue añadida al Cristianismo en elConcilio de Nicea que tuvo lugar y fue celebrado unos 325 años después de lapartida de Jesús de la Tierra. Nótese que indico que partió de la Tierra y no que este muriera, este esotro tópico para otro día.
Regresandoa la Doctrina del Pecado Original, demos una mirada a los siguientes pasajes dela Biblia. (Deuteronomio24:16) “Los padres no morirán por culpa de los hijos ni los hijos por culpa delos padres. Cada cual morirá por su propio pecado.”(Jeremías 31:29-30): 31:29 En aquellos días, nose dirá más: Los padres comieron uva verde y los hijos sufren la dentera. 31:30 No, cada uno morirá por supropia iniquidad:
todo el que coma uva verde sufrirá la dentera.todo el que coma uva verde sufrirá la dentera.todo el que coma uva verde sufrirá la dentera.(Ezequiel 18:20): La persona que peca, esa morirá; el hijo no cargarácon las culpas del padre, ni el padre cargará con las culpas del hijo. Sobre eljusto recaerá su justicia, y sobre el malvado, su maldad.
¿Con todo el debido respeto y despuésde leer los versos arriba citados, no estamos entonces de acuerdo en que cadacual es responsable por sus propios actos? ¿ Que nos dice sobre este particularel Sagrado Libro del Corán?“Nadie cargará con la carga ajena. Y si alguien, abrumado por su carga,pide ayuda a otro, no se le ayudará nada, aunque sea pariente. Tú sólo debesadvertir a los que tienen miedo de su Señor en secreto y hacen la azalá. Quiense purifica se purifica en realidad, en provecho propio. ¡Dios es el fin detodo! “ (Corán 35:18) “Temedun día en que nadie pueda satisfacer nada por otro, ni se acepte la intercesiónajena, compensación ni auxilio.” Surah 2 (AlBaqara), Aleya # 48 : Aparenta ser que tanto la Biblia como el Coran estánde acuerdo en este asunto. Y segúnprofundizamos en este camino en búsqueda de la verdad vemos como esto se repitecon más frecuencia.Por favor sigan atentos y en sintoníacon nuestro Programa de Radio Semanal Islam4mankind, todos los jueves de 1:10pm hasta las 2:00 pm por La Mágica 1220 am, donde en estas semanas estamosdiscutiendo el tema sobre “Los Profetas”. Próximamente haremos un programasobre “El Pecado o La Bondad Original” que sabemos será para el deleite einstrucción de toda nuestra audiencia.
Veamos varios videos sobre el tema en discusión yregresaremos a nuestra conversación inicial.
The Holy Prophet (S) said. “One who displeases the parents, (it is as if) he has displeased Allah. One who angers both his parents (it is as if) he has angered Allah.” Elsewhere, it is mentioned, “One who hurts his parents, hurts me and one who hurts me has hurt Allah. And the one who hurts Allah is accursed.” Āq al-Walidayn is Not Eligible For Divine Forgiveness The wretchedness of the Āq al-Walidayn is sufficiently evident from the fact that the trustworthy Jibrīl (a.s.) has cursed him and said, “One who is blessed with parents but does not fulfill their (his parent’s) rights will not be forgiven (his sins) by Allah.” 3 When Jibrīl (a.s.) said this, the Holy Prophet (S) uttered, ‘Amen’! DONT disrespect, shout, ignore, annoy, disobey, disregard, disturb our parents. They were looking after us when we were nothing but an easy prey to anything around. They were awake during the nights to make us sleep and feel us secured. We may not remember a thing in the childhoo...
People ask me all the time, Why don't you eat pork? ...Is it for religious reasons? ...Are you vegetarian? Are you a Muslim or a Jew ? Do you know that pork taste good ? Honestly, just today I was even asked for sound scientific evidence affirming the danger of eating pork. I will share a few findings with you. Medical and Scientific Reasons for not Eating Pork: This is a direct quote from "What the Bible Says About Healthy Eating" by Dr. Rex Russell. He attended Baylor School of Medicine in Houston, Texas and did his residency at the Mayo Clinic at Rochester, Minnesota. Let us watch this short video , let the conversation begin: "One reason for God's rule forbidding pork is that the digestive system of a pig is completely different from that of a cow. It is similar to ours, in that the stomach is very acidic. Pigs are gluttonous, never knowing when to stop eating. Their stomach acids become diluted because of the volume of food, allowing all kind...
A letter to Jehovah Witness by Rachidm: Dear Jehovah’s Witnesses: I would like to share with you some biblical research based upon my discussions with Jehovah’s Witnesses friends. My wife used to be a Jehovah Witness. When we got married, I, as a Muslim told her ; "you have the right to practice your religion". I even offered to give her a ride if needed to the Kingdom hall ( Jehovah Witness place of worship ) . With an open mind, I supported her and told her I would never mind her practicing and preaching her religion. During our first couple years of blessed and happy marriage together, I was privileged to engage with my parents in law (upon their request) in a comparative study between Islam and their beliefs. Although they were discouraged from dialogue since they believe their way is the only correct way, I always enjoyed a good open discussion about religion in general. My Mom in law offered me a copy of the New World Translation...
A letter to Jehovah Witness by Rachidm: Dear Jehovah’s Witnesses: I would like to share with you some biblical research based upon my discussions with Jehovah’s Witnesses friends. My wife used to be a Jehovah Witness. When we got married, I, as a Muslim told her ; "you have the right to practice your religion". I even offered to give her a ride if needed to the Kingdom hall ( Jehovah Witness place of worship ) . With an open mind, I supported her and told her I would never mind her practicing and preaching her religion. During our first couple years of blessed and happy marriage together, I was privileged to engage with my parents in law (upon their request) in a comparative study between Islam and their beliefs. Although they were discouraged from dialogue since they believe their way is the only correct way, I always enjoyed a good open discussion about religion in general. My Mom in law offered me a copy of the New World Translation ...
The idea of Jesus dying on the cross is central to the Christian belief. It represents the conviction that Jesus died for the sins of mankind. The crucifixion of Jesus is a vital doctrine in Christianity; however Muslims reject it completely. Before describing what Muslims believe about Jesus’ crucifixion, it may be useful to understand the Islamic reaction to the notion of original sin. When Adam and Eve ate from the forbidden tree in paradise, they were not tempted by a serpent. It was Satan who deceived and cajoled them, whereupon they exercised their free will and made an error in judgement. Eve does not bear the burden of this mistake alone. Together, Adam and Eve realised their disobedience, felt remorse and begged for God’s forgiveness. God, in his infinite mercy and wisdom, forgave them. Islam has no concept of original sin; each person bears responsibility for his own deeds. “And no bearer of burdens shall bear another’s bur...
Greetings of peace, This post is an answer to a new friend whom I recently met and respect , a devout Christian passionate about sharing his religion with others , who challenged me to provide some proofs regarding why Muslims don't accept the doctrine of original sin; a doctrine ( including the concept of trinity ) that was added by the Church at the Council of Nicaea some 325 years after Jesus left the earth. Notice I say left the earth ( meaning resurected alive by Allah ) and not died yet or crucify as some claims , but that is a topic for another day. Back to the doctrine of original sin. Are we born with so called Original sin or born innocent ? Is a Newly Born Baby really a Sinner? Islam Challenges The Concept of Original Sin. Let us found out why ? let's take a look at the following passages from The Bible: (Deuteronomy 24:16) “The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children...
Please tune in today to your weekly radio program Islam4mankind starting from 1:07 to 2 pm live from radio station Laprimira1220 am station Allah is the Most Generous : Main Points 1. The Oneness of Almighty in His Lordship, Godhood and Attributes. 2. Allah's Attributes are expression of His Greatness and Love. 3. What the Qur'an says about Allah's Attributes. 4. What the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said about the Attributes of Allah, the Almighty God. 5. Allah is the Most Generous as emphasized by the Qur'an and the traditions of Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) . 6. Manifestations of Allah's Generosity. 7. Our responsibility towards this great Attribute of the Almighty God. Was-Salamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullaahi Wa Barakatuh Dr. EL SAYED RAMADAN, PhD Lecturer at Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt Department Of Islamic Studies In English Imam of Masjid Fresno Islamic Center ...
Imam Abdul Malik serves as the director of Community Outreach for the Dar Al-Hijrah Islamic Center. He was the first Muslim Chaplain installed at Howard University. The imam is the former chair of Government Relations for the Muslim Alliance in North America [MANA founded by Imam Siraj Wahhaj] and is the founding President of the Muslim Society of Washington, DC Inc. Known nationally for his fundraising efforts for masjids, schools and relief organizations, Imam Johari is a founding member of the Muslim Advocacy Commission of Washington, D.C. and “Muslim Men Against Domestic Violence” [MMADV] and has edited a book on “What Islam Says About Domestic Violence”. In his native Brooklyn community his mother kept the family busy with community service. From an Episcopal choir boy-who visited the deep southern Pentecostal “COGIC” holiness church during his summer vacations as youth-until at confirmation the teachings of the Ten Commandments exposed what he believed were contradictions wit...
